Rankings Towns Reviews About Joe Recommend a Spot Full Rankings

Home/Rankings

The Full Leaderboard

Every Buffalo pizzeria Joe has ranked

236 pizzerias across 19 towns, sorted by Joe’s score. Filter by town, search by name, or sort by price to find the best pie near you.

9.4Top score

236Pizzerias ranked

$22.71Average price

24Towns

Rank

Pizzeria

Town

Price

Joe’s Score

Pizzeria FlorianEast Aurora, NY

9.4

Macy's Place PizzeriaKenmore, NY

9.3

Buffalo Deep DishBuffalo, NY

9.1

John's Pizza & Subs (Niagara Falls Blvd)Tonawanda, NY

9.1

Marble & RyeBuffalo, NY

9.1

Picasso's PizzaWest Seneca, NY

9.1

Papa's Pizza Oven at Legacy Sports BarWest Seneca, NY

9.0

Picasso's PizzaLancaster, NY

9.0

Tony's PizzaCheektowaga, NY

9.0

Bailey Avenue PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.9

DiPaulo's PizzeriaTonawanda, NY

8.9

Favorites Pizza & WingsLewiston, NY

8.9

Ferro's Famous NY PizzaWest Seneca, NY

8.9

Lovejoy PizzeriaBuffalo, NY

8.9

Mattina's PizzeriaWilliamsville, NY

8.9

Nino's PizzeriaHamburg, NY

8.9

Pesci's Pizza & WingsBuffalo, NY

8.9

Poplar PizzaCheektowaga, NY

8.9

Sammy's PizzeriaNiagara Falls, NY

8.9

Wayland Brewing CompanyOrchard Park, NY

8.9

Gino's Pizza PlaceTonawanda, NY

8.8

Grandma D's PizzeriaYoungstown, NY

8.8

JJ's Casa Di PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.8

La Bella SiciliaCheektowaga, NY

8.8

Leo's PizzeriaLancaster, NY

8.8

Macy's Place PizzeriaCheektowaga, NY

8.8

Master PizzaCheektowaga, NY

8.8

Niagara Deli & PizzeriaBuffalo, NY

8.8

Papa's Pizza Oven (Abbott Rd)Buffalo, NY

8.8

Pizza By Molino'sBuffalo, NY

8.8

The 33 Speakeasy GrillCheektowaga, NY

8.8

Airport PizzaCheektowaga, NY

8.7

Cappelli's PizzeriaOrchard Park, NY

8.7

Carbone's PizzeriaAlden, NY

8.7

D'Agostino's PizzeriaDepew, NY

8.7

Edie's Pizza and SubsHamburg, NY

8.7

Great Lakes PizzaWest Seneca, NY

8.7

Hustler's TavernLewiston, NY

8.7

Imperial PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.7

Johnny's Pizzeria & RestaurantCheektowaga, NY

8.7

La Hacienda Ristorante and PizzeriaNiagara Falls, NY

8.7

Mia Mangia PizzeriaDepew, NY

8.7

Mister B's RestaurantNiagara Falls, NY

8.7

Pizza AmoreNorth Tonawanda, NY

North Tonawanda

8.7

Sugo's PizzaCheektowaga, NY

8.7

Bozzy's PizzeriaCheektowaga, NY

8.6

Brick Oven Pizzeria & PubGrand Island, NY

8.6

Caputi's Sheridan PubTonawanda, NY

8.6

Casa Nova RestaurantNiagara Falls, NY

8.6

Chick N Pizza WorksBuffalo, NY

8.6

Deniro's PizzeriaDepew, NY

8.6

Emergency PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.6

Franco's PizzaTonawanda, NY

8.6

Frenchy's PizzeriaNiagara Falls, NY

8.6

Gandy's PizzaCheektowaga, NY

8.6

Good Guys PizzaNorth Tonawanda, NY

North Tonawanda

8.6

Just Pizza & Wing Co.Buffalo, NY

8.6

Mister M's House of Food & DrinkNiagara Falls, NY

8.6

Mustachio's PizzeriaBuffalo, NY

8.6

Papa's Pizza OvenAmherst, NY

8.6

Pat's PizzeriaBuffalo, NY

8.6

Pizza Amore the Woodfire WayGrand Island, NY

8.6

Santora's Pizza Drive-InDepew, NY

8.6

Zetti's Pizza & PastaAmherst, NY

8.6

Bob & John's La HaciendaBuffalo, NY

8.5

Broadway PizzaNiagara Falls, NY

8.5

Buffalo Bites PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.5

Frankie's Donuts and PizzaNiagara Falls, NY

8.5

Jay's Artisan PizzeriaKenmore, NY

8.5

Jocko's Pizza and PastaCheektowaga, NY

8.5

Joe's New York Style PizzaTonawanda, NY

8.5

John & Mary's PizzaAlden, NY

8.5

La Hacienda BrightonTonawanda, NY

8.5

Main Street PizzeriaYoungstown, NY

8.5

Mister PizzaAmherst, NY

8.5

Moon's PizzaDepew, NY

8.5

Muscarella's PizzaWilliamsville, NY

8.5

One Pie Pizza CoWest Seneca, NY

8.5

Pasquale's Italian RestaurantWest Seneca, NY

8.5

Ricotta's Pizza NiagaraBuffalo, NY

8.5

Rix Country StoreOrchard Park, NY

8.5

Vargo's Pizzeria RestaurantLancaster, NY

8.5

716 Supreme SubsNiagara Falls, NY

8.4

Artone's Pizza & SubsBuffalo, NY

8.4

Brando's Pizza & WingsNiagara Falls, NY

8.4

Franco's Pizza (Niagara Falls Blvd)Tonawanda, NY

8.4

Galassi's Sub ShopNorth Tonawanda, NY

North Tonawanda

8.4

Grasso's PizzaDepew, NY

8.4

Mangia Ristorante & CaffeOrchard Park, NY

8.4

Muscarella's PizzeriaLancaster, NY

8.4

Naked City PizzaKenmore, NY

8.4

Neat PizzaDepew, NY

8.4

Pane's RestaurantNorth Tonawanda, NY

North Tonawanda

8.4

Papa J's Pizza Bar and GrillCheektowaga, NY

8.4

Pappaceno's PizzaOrchard Park, NY

8.4

The Original Pizza ShackWheatfield, NY

8.4

The Original Ventry's Pizza ShopNiagara Falls, NY

8.4

The Pizza HeistLancaster, NY

8.4

Trattoria AromaWilliamsville, NY

8.4

VinLouie's PizzeriaHamburg, NY

8.4

Bocce Club PizzaAmherst, NY

8.3

Campobello's PizzaAmherst, NY

8.3

Desi's PizzeriaBuffalo, NY

8.3

Doino's Pizzeria Bar & GrilleCheektowaga, NY

8.3

Fatman's PizzaTonawanda, NY

8.3

Gagster's Restaurant & CateringNiagara Falls, NY

8.3

Gino & Joe's PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.3

Joey's PizzaDepew, NY

8.3

Mayor's PizzaNorth Tonawanda, NY

North Tonawanda

8.3

Papa Leo's PizzeriaWheatfield, NY

8.3

Penora's PizzaDepew, NY

8.3

Strikers LanesWest Seneca, NY

8.3

A Touch of ItalyTonawanda, NY

8.2

Blasdell PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.2

Chuck's North Street SubwayBuffalo, NY

8.2

DanielaBuffalo, NY

8.2

Diva's PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.2

Geoffano's PizzeriaAlden, NY

8.2

Gianni Mazia's on MainClarence, NY

8.2

John's Pizza & SubsGrand Island, NY

8.2

Just Pizza & Wing Co.Tonawanda, NY

8.2

LT's Pizza and SubsWest Seneca, NY

8.2

LaPorta's PizzeriaWilliamsville, NY

8.2

Mark's PizzeriaLockport, NY

8.2

Mayback's PizzeriaCheektowaga, NY

8.2

Michael's RestaurantNiagara Falls, NY

8.2

Mineo's South PizzeriaBuffalo, NY

8.2

Nino's PizzaWest Seneca, NY

8.2

Picasso's PizzaBlasdell, NY

8.2

Pie O MineTonawanda, NY

8.2

Roz's PizzeriaCheektowaga, NY

8.2

Sorrentino's Spaghetti HouseWilliamsville, NY

8.2

Vincenzo's Pizza HouseLewiston, NY

8.2

Wise Guys PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.2

240 South Pub & GrillWest Seneca, NY

8.1

Brick Oven Bistro & DeliBuffalo, NY

8.1

Buzzy's PizzeriaNiagara Falls, NY

8.1

Jocko's PizzeriaNiagara Falls, NY

8.1

Joey's PizzeriaNiagara Falls, NY

8.1

La Pizza ClubBuffalo, NY

8.1

Leo's PizzeriaBuffalo, NY

8.1

Mister SubmarineBuffalo, NY

8.1

Molinaro's RistoranteLockport, NY

8.1

OP Social Tap and GrilleOrchard Park, NY

8.1

Rob's Topico PizzaClarence, NY

8.1

Ronny's Take Out PizzaLancaster, NY

8.1

T.C. Wheelers Bar & PizzeriaTonawanda, NY

8.1

Bella PizzaLackawanna, NY

8.0

Kensington PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.0

Lock 34 Bar & GrillLockport, NY

8.0

Marco's Italian RestaurantBuffalo, NY

8.0

Old Greenwalls RestaurantNiagara Falls, NY

8.0

Palumbo's PizzeriaTonawanda, NY

8.0

Allentown PizzaBuffalo, NY

7.9

Buck's PizzeriaNiagara Falls, NY

7.9

Carbone's Pizza & SubsBuffalo, NY

7.9

Franco's PizzaNorth Tonawanda, NY

North Tonawanda

7.9

George's PizzaNiagara Falls, NY

7.9

Ghada Have It!Niagara Falls, NY

7.9

JT's PizzaTonawanda, NY

7.9

John's Pizza & Subs (Delaware Ave)Tonawanda, NY

7.9

Kith & Kin BakeshopLockport, NY

7.9

La Nova PizzeriaAmherst, NY

7.9

Metro Pizza CoBuffalo, NY

7.9

Mister Pizza ElmwoodBuffalo, NY

7.9

Papa Leo's PizzeriaLockport, NY

7.9

Pie O MineOrchard Park, NY

7.9

Pino's PizzaOrchard Park, NY

7.9

Sanger Farm & BakeryYoungstown, NY

7.9

Amherst Pizza and Ale HouseAmherst, NY

7.8

Bada Bing Bar & GrillBuffalo, NY

7.8

Butera's Craft Beer & Craft PizzaHamburg, NY

7.8

Duff's Famous WingsWilliamsville, NY

7.8

Franco's PizzaBuffalo, NY

7.8

Jo Jo's Pizza & SubsBuffalo, NY

7.8

La Nova PizzeriaBuffalo, NY

7.8

Leon's Italian Bistro & PizzaNiagara Falls, NY

7.8

Sunny's Family RestaurantLockport, NY

7.8

Town Line PizzaAlden, NY

7.8

Abbott Road PizzaBuffalo, NY

7.7

Anjon's PizzeriaOrchard Park, NY

7.7

LaRosa PizzaNiagara Falls, NY

7.7

Olisi's New York Style PizzaTonawanda, NY

7.7

Plaza Pizzeria on MainTonawanda, NY

7.7

Rocco's Wood Fired PizzaWilliamsville, NY

7.7

Sub DeliciousLockport, NY

7.7

Extra Extra PizzaBuffalo, NY

7.6

Giacobbi's Cucina CittaBuffalo, NY

7.6

Mr. Ventry's Pizza on the BoulevardNiagara Falls, NY

7.6

Queen City PizzaAmherst, NY

7.6

Riva's PizzeriaDepew, NY

7.6

Wally's Cafe and PizzeriaCheektowaga, NY

7.6

The Grill on ErieNorth Tonawanda, NY

North Tonawanda

7.5

The Penalty BoxLockport, NY

7.5

Dandelions RestaurantWilliamsville, NY

7.4

Goodfellas PizzeriaNiagara Falls, NY

7.4

Luigi's Pizza and CateringAmherst, NY

7.4

Raintree Bar and GrillTonawanda, NY

7.4

TK's PizzaWest Seneca, NY

7.4

Jet's PizzaBuffalo, NY

7.3

Pizza & Chicken DelightsBuffalo, NY

7.3

The Wurlitzer Pizza CoNorth Tonawanda, NY

North Tonawanda

7.3

Tony's PizzaSanborn, NY

7.3

Yubb's RestaurantNiagara Falls, NY

7.3

Fra Amici Pizza & PastaBuffalo, NY

7.2

John & Mary's PizzaHamburg, NY

7.2

Pizza OvenLockport, NY

7.2

Romeo & Juliet's Bakery and CafeTonawanda, NY

7.1

Say Cheese Pizza CoGrand Island, NY

7.1

Pizza Plant Italian PubWilliamsville, NY

6.9

Alden Express and DeliAlden, NY

6.8

Blaze PizzaAmherst, NY

6.8

Crosby'sWest Seneca, NY

6.8

D'Avolio KitchenWilliamsville, NY

6.8

Tallarico's PizzeriaWheatfield, NY

6.8

West Seneca PizzaWest Seneca, NY

6.8

Pizza OvenNiagara Falls, NY

6.7

Ying's Restaurant & BarDepew, NY

6.6

My Tomato PieAmherst, NY

6.4

The Byrd HouseOrchard Park, NY

6.4

Delta Sonic Brick Oven KitchenWest Seneca, NY

6.3

Hunt Brothers PizzaGrand Island, NY

6.3

David's 716 Bar & GrillNiagara Falls, NY

6.1

Osteria 166Buffalo, NY

5.9

Union PubBuffalo, NY

5.9

Buffalo Pizza ProjectNorth Tonawanda, NY

North Tonawanda

5.7

KFC ChizzaBuffalo, NY

5.6

Bocce Club Pizza (Buffalo Airport)Cheektowaga, NY

5.5

SubwayOrchard Park, NY

5.5

WegmansWilliamsville, NY

5.3

Chuck E. CheeseBlasdell, NY

5.2

Queen City Kitchen (Buffalo Airport)Cheektowaga, NY

4.9

Little CaesarsLockport, NY

4.5

7-ElevenLackawanna, NY

2.5

Prime Food & Meat MarketBuffalo, NY

2.1

Anchor BarBuffalo, NY

0.0

No pizzerias match that search yet. Try another town or name.

How the list works

One judge. One scale.

Every pizzeria on this list was visited by Pizza Review Joe and scored on camera. The same person scores every pie, so a 8.6 in Amherst means the same thing as a 8.6 in Niagara Falls.

Prices are what Joe paid on the day of his visit, so they’re a guide, not a menu. Scores and rankings update as new reviews go up.

Jump to a town

Buffalo52 Niagara Falls27 Tonawanda20 Cheektowaga19 West Seneca14 Amherst11 Depew11 Orchard Park11 Williamsville11 Lockport10 North Tonawanda9 Lancaster6 Alden5 Grand Island5 Hamburg5 Kenmore3 Lewiston3 Wheatfield3 Youngstown3

Know a spot Joe missed?

Send it in. The best tips become the next review on the channel.

Recommend a Pizzeria