Meet Pizza Review Joe
Hundreds of pizzerias. Thousands of slices. One honest score at a time.
Just a guy who loves pizza
Pizza Review Joe started with a simple idea: walk into a pizzeria, order, pay, and tell people the truth about the pie on camera.
That idea turned into hundreds of reviews across Buffalo and Niagara, and a channel that local pizza lovers use to decide where to order next. Best Pizza Buffalo pulls every one of those Buffalo reviews into one place so you can find a great pie fast.
No sponsors pick the stops. No owner pays for a better score. If a famous name disappoints, Joe says so. If a tiny corner shop blows him away, it goes straight to the top of the list.
Watch on YouTubeWhat the scores mean
Every pizzeria gets one score out of 10. Here’s how to read it.
Every stop, same process
Walk in like anyone else
No heads-up to the owner, no special treatment. Joe orders and pays at the counter.
Taste it on camera
Crust, sauce, cheese, toppings and value. You see exactly what he sees and hear exactly what he thinks.
Give it a score
One number out of 10. Every score goes on the leaderboard so you can compare pizzerias across Buffalo.
More from Joe
The channel
Every review, start to finish. Subscribe so you never miss a new stop.
review.pizzaReviews everywhere
Joe’s reviews from beyond Buffalo, plus pages pizzeria owners can claim.
For ownersPizzaPhone
An AI receptionist built for pizzerias that answers every call, even on a slammed Friday night.
Know a spot Joe missed?
Send it in. The best tips become the next review on the channel.