The best pizza
in Buffalo,
ranked.
One guy. One camera. 236 pizzerias across Buffalo, Niagara Falls, the Northtowns and the Southtowns, scored on camera so you know exactly where to order tonight.
Pizzeria Florian
East Aurora, NY · $27.19Buffalo’s Top 10
Every score comes from a real visit and a real video. No sponsors, no paid placements.
Best pizza by town
From downtown Buffalo to the Falls, here’s the top-rated pie in every town Joe has covered.
Best Pizza in Buffalo
Best Pizza in Niagara Falls
Best Pizza in Tonawanda
Best Pizza in Cheektowaga
Best Pizza in West Seneca
Best Pizza in Amherst
Best Pizza in Depew
Best of Buffalo
Best Under $20
Top-rated pies that won’t wreck your wallet.
- Buffalo Deep Dish9.1
- Sammy's Pizzeria8.9
- Grandma D's Pizzeria8.8
Best in the City
The highest scores inside Buffalo.
- Buffalo Deep Dish9.1
- Marble & Rye9.1
- Bailey Avenue Pizza8.9
Northtowns Heavyweights
Tonawanda, Kenmore, Amherst, Williamsville and the rest of the Northtowns.
- Macy's Place Pizzeria9.3
- John's Pizza & Subs (Niagara Falls Blvd)9.1
- DiPaulo's Pizzeria8.9
Real visits. Real scores. Every time.
Joe walks in, orders, pays like everyone else, and scores the pie on camera. No free food, no paid placements, no deals with owners.
That’s how a small-town pizzeria can beat the most famous names in Buffalo, and why people trust the list.
Tell Joe where to go next
Got a Buffalo pizzeria that deserves a review? Send it in and it could be the next stop on the channel.
Recommend a PizzeriaGot reviewed? Claim your listing.
Claim your free page on review.pizza, and see how PizzaPhone answers every call so you never miss an order on a busy Friday night.