Rankings Towns Reviews About Joe Recommend a Spot Full Rankings
Home/Rankings/Best Pizza in the Southtowns
Joe’s Short List

Best of the Southtowns

The best pizza in West Seneca, Orchard Park, Hamburg, Lackawanna, Blasdell and East Aurora, ranked together.

35Pizzerias
9.4Top score
$22.97Average price
Rank
Pizzeria
Town
Price
Joe’s Score
01
Pizzeria FlorianEast Aurora, NY
East Aurora
$27.19
9.4
02
Picasso's PizzaWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$29.85
9.1
03
Papa's Pizza Oven at Legacy Sports BarWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$30.44
9.0
04
Ferro's Famous NY PizzaWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$28.80
8.9
05
Nino's PizzeriaHamburg, NY
Hamburg
$27.80
8.9
06
Wayland Brewing CompanyOrchard Park, NY
Orchard Park
$20.66
8.9
07
Cappelli's PizzeriaOrchard Park, NY
Orchard Park
$29.80
8.7
08
Edie's Pizza and SubsHamburg, NY
Hamburg
$26.80
8.7
09
Great Lakes PizzaWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$23.64
8.7
10
One Pie Pizza CoWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$24.99
8.5
11
Pasquale's Italian RestaurantWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$25.00
8.5
12
Rix Country StoreOrchard Park, NY
Orchard Park
$21.73
8.5
13
Mangia Ristorante & CaffeOrchard Park, NY
Orchard Park
$11.96
8.4
14
Pappaceno's PizzaOrchard Park, NY
Orchard Park
$25.80
8.4
15
VinLouie's PizzeriaHamburg, NY
Hamburg
$24.47
8.4
16
Strikers LanesWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$22.30
8.3
17
LT's Pizza and SubsWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$23.69
8.2
18
Nino's PizzaWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$27.82
8.2
19
Picasso's PizzaBlasdell, NY
Blasdell
$32.67
8.2
20
240 South Pub & GrillWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$17.17
8.1
21
OP Social Tap and GrilleOrchard Park, NY
Orchard Park
$21.75
8.1
22
Bella PizzaLackawanna, NY
Lackawanna
$25.50
8.0
23
Pie O MineOrchard Park, NY
Orchard Park
$21.74
7.9
24
Pino's PizzaOrchard Park, NY
Orchard Park
$23.38
7.9
25
Butera's Craft Beer & Craft PizzaHamburg, NY
Hamburg
$17.15
7.8
26
Anjon's PizzeriaOrchard Park, NY
Orchard Park
$24.99
7.7
27
TK's PizzaWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$20.65
7.4
28
John & Mary's PizzaHamburg, NY
Hamburg
$23.14
7.2
29
Crosby'sWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$19.20
6.8
30
West Seneca PizzaWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$18.48
6.8
31
The Byrd HouseOrchard Park, NY
Orchard Park
$24.60
6.4
32
Delta Sonic Brick Oven KitchenWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$16.30
6.3
33
SubwayOrchard Park, NY
Orchard Park
$9.78
5.5
34
Chuck E. CheeseBlasdell, NY
Blasdell
$26.90
5.2
35
7-ElevenLackawanna, NY
Lackawanna
$7.92
2.5
On Camera

Watch the top picks

West Seneca, Orchard Park, Hamburg and the rest of the Southtowns, on camera.

Pizzeria Florian pizza review
9.4

Pizzeria Florian

East Aurora, NY · $27.19
Picasso's Pizza pizza review
9.1

Picasso's Pizza

West Seneca, NY · $29.85
Papa's Pizza Oven at Legacy Sports Bar pizza review
9.0

Papa's Pizza Oven at Legacy Sports Bar

West Seneca, NY · $30.44
Ferro's Famous NY Pizza pizza review
8.9

Ferro's Famous NY Pizza

West Seneca, NY · $28.80

Know a spot Joe missed?

Send it in. The best tips become the next review on the channel.

Recommend a Pizzeria