Home/Reviews
Every Buffalo review

Joe’s Buffalo pizza reviews

237 pizzerias. Every one ordered, paid for and scored on camera. Watch the video, read the write-up, then go get a slice.

237Pizzerias reviewed
24Towns covered
9.4Top score
Wegmans pizza

Wegmans Review – Williamsville, NY

August 05, 2024•1 min read
5.3
Joe’s
score
Price$16.80 · Large cheese pepperoni
LocationWilliamsville, NY

This Wegmans grocery store is on Sheridan Drive in Williamsville. A viewer recommended trying the pizza through review.pizza.

The order

Joe ordered online for $16.80 and wasn't able to tip. It looked like a 14 or 16-inch large cheese pepperoni, with lay flat pepperoni. When he got there it was sitting in a warming tray, and he could just grab it and go. The cut was a little rough right out of the gate.

First bite

Medium light browning, with a checkered pattern underneath that looked like it was done on a screen. The sauce was the first thing Joe noticed, and it did not do it for him.

Crust, sauce, cheese and toppings

  • Crust: Medium thickness with a softish texture, though Joe could barely taste it.
  • Sauce: A weird flavor. It almost reminded Joe of pizza sauce in Cuba. He said it's hurting the pizza.
  • Cheese: Better than the pepperoni.
  • Pepperoni: Mediocre.

What would make it better

Just changing the sauce would improve it a lot.

The verdict

If Joe was walking through the store and had to eat, it's okay, but that sauce really kills it. He gave it a 5.3.

Find Wegmans

Sheridan Dr, Williamsville, NY

View on GoogleGet Directions

More Buffalo pizza

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez is Pizza Review Joe, the Canadian pizza reviewer who crosses the border to find the best pie in Buffalo and Niagara. He walks in, orders, pays, and scores every pizza on camera, one honest number out of 10.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog