My Tomato Pie Review – Amherst, NY
6.4
Joe’s
score
score
Price$22.84 · Large cheese pepperoni
LocationAmherst, NY
My Tomato Pie on Niagara Falls Boulevard in Amherst had all the right pieces, but one problem dragged it down.
The order
Joe ordered a large cheese pepperoni for $22.84. It came with cup and char pepperoni and looked saucy and a little thick.
First bite
The crispy pepperoni was great, and the flavors worked together. The dough didn't.
Crust, sauce, cheese and toppings
- Crust: Good flavor but undercooked: doughy, squishy and chewy on the back.
- Sauce: Takes a back seat to everything else.
- Pepperoni: Crispy and tasty. Joe loved it.
- Cook: Light underneath. This was the big issue.
What would make it better
More time in the oven. Joe would love to try this pizza again cooked all the way through.
The verdict
There's good potential at My Tomato Pie, but the undercooked crust pulled it down to a 6.4.
Find My Tomato Pie
3055 Niagara Falls Blvd, Amherst, NY 14228
