Mayor's Pizza Review – North Tonawanda, NY
8.3
Joe’s
score
score
Price$21.55 · Large 18-inch cheese pepperoni
LocationNorth Tonawanda, NY
Mayor's Pizza is on Oliver Street in North Tonawanda. A viewer named Mike Riley recommended it on review.pizza.
The order
Joe ordered a large 18-inch cheese pepperoni for $21.55, which he called a good price. The box was taped shut and freshly sealed. It's cut into 12 slices, with cup and char and plenty of sauce.
First bite
Joe liked the color underneath. It's a little dark, but he doesn't think it's burnt. If it were, he'd taste it, and he didn't. It's thin and cheesy.
Crust, sauce, cheese and toppings
- Crust: Soft even with the dark bottom. It goes from thin to just a little thicker on the outside.
- Sauce: What stands out most. Sweeter, but with good flavor, not just sugary.
- Cheese: Beautiful, though one side had more cheese than the other and the outside was missing some.
- Pepperoni: Cup and char.
What would make it better
Joe would like a sauce that's a little more mellow and lets the tomato shine through more than the sugar.
The verdict
Joe liked the crust and the flavors are great. He gave Mayor's an 8.3, a solid pizza.
Find Mayor's Pizza
452 Oliver St, North Tonawanda, NY 14120
