Mayback's Pizzeria Review – Cheektowaga, NY
8.2
Joe’s
score
score
Price$17.39 · Large cheese pepperoni
LocationCheektowaga, NY
Mayback's Pizzeria is on Genesee Street in Cheektowaga. A viewer recommended it on review.pizza.
The order
Joe ordered a large 18-inch cheese pepperoni for $17.39, likely the cheapest pizza he'd had in Cheektowaga. It came with lay flat pepperoni, not cup and char, which Joe thought might explain the price.
First bite
Medium thickness, hot, with leopard browning underneath and a mouthful of cheese. Cheese heaven.
Crust, sauce, cheese and toppings
- Crust: Good.
- Sauce: The amount is proper, but it's a little heavy on the herbs for Joe.
- Cheese: The shining star by a long shot. Creamy and fantastic. Joe wants to know what cheese they use.
- Pepperoni: Lay flat is fine, but Joe would like it better with cup and char.
What would make it better
Cup and char pepperoni, and either fewer herbs or a different sauce.
The verdict
This pizza is fantastic and the cheese is amazing. Joe gave it an 8.2, and at that price it might be the best pizza deal in Cheektowaga.
Find Mayback's Pizzeria
3035 Genesee St #7, Buffalo, NY 14225
