Rank
Pizzeria
Town
Price
Joe’s Score
01
Buffalo Deep DishBuffalo, NY
Buffalo
$17.75
02
Sammy's PizzeriaNiagara Falls, NY
Niagara Falls
$17.05
03
Grandma D's PizzeriaYoungstown, NY
Youngstown
$18.50
04
La Bella SiciliaCheektowaga, NY
Cheektowaga
$18.22
05
Carbone's PizzeriaAlden, NY
Alden
$18.92
06
Mister B's RestaurantNiagara Falls, NY
Niagara Falls
$19.39
07
Caputi's Sheridan PubTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$15.22
08
Deniro's PizzeriaDepew, NY
Depew
$18.48
09
Frankie's Donuts and PizzaNiagara Falls, NY
Niagara Falls
$17.50
10
Jay's Artisan PizzeriaKenmore, NY
Kenmore
$18.45
11
Moon's PizzaDepew, NY
Depew
$15.50
12
716 Supreme SubsNiagara Falls, NY
Niagara Falls
$16.20
13
Mangia Ristorante & CaffeOrchard Park, NY
Orchard Park
$11.96
14
Naked City PizzaKenmore, NY
Kenmore
$15.50
15
The Original Ventry's Pizza ShopNiagara Falls, NY
Niagara Falls
$17.00
16
The Pizza HeistLancaster, NY
Lancaster
$18.48
17
Trattoria AromaWilliamsville, NY
Williamsville
$19.58
18
Penora's PizzaDepew, NY
Depew
$16.00
19
DanielaBuffalo, NY
Buffalo
$15.60
20
Geoffano's PizzeriaAlden, NY
Alden
$18.48
21
Mayback's PizzeriaCheektowaga, NY
Cheektowaga
$17.39
22
Michael's RestaurantNiagara Falls, NY
Niagara Falls
$15.00
23
240 South Pub & GrillWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$17.17
24
Brick Oven Bistro & DeliBuffalo, NY
Buffalo
$15.77
25
Buzzy's PizzeriaNiagara Falls, NY
Niagara Falls
$18.85
26
Joey's PizzeriaNiagara Falls, NY
Niagara Falls
$17.70
27
Mister SubmarineBuffalo, NY
Buffalo
$19.10
28
Ronny's Take Out PizzaLancaster, NY
Lancaster
$19.56
29
Lock 34 Bar & GrillLockport, NY
Lockport
$8.64
30
Palumbo's PizzeriaTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$16.85
31
Buck's PizzeriaNiagara Falls, NY
Niagara Falls
$19.00
32
George's PizzaNiagara Falls, NY
Niagara Falls
$16.76
33
Ghada Have It!Niagara Falls, NY
Niagara Falls
$16.19
34
Kith & Kin BakeshopLockport, NY
Lockport
$14.31
35
Sanger Farm & BakeryYoungstown, NY
Youngstown
$18.36
36
Butera's Craft Beer & Craft PizzaHamburg, NY
Hamburg
$17.15
37
Leon's Italian Bistro & PizzaNiagara Falls, NY
Niagara Falls
$16.74
38
Mr. Ventry's Pizza on the BoulevardNiagara Falls, NY
Niagara Falls
$18.36
39
The Penalty BoxLockport, NY
Lockport
$18.89
40
Jet's PizzaBuffalo, NY
Buffalo
$17.99
41
Yubb's RestaurantNiagara Falls, NY
Niagara Falls
$10.00
42
Romeo & Juliet's Bakery and CafeTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$19.58
43
Blaze PizzaAmherst, NY
Amherst
$15.17
44
Crosby'sWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$19.20
45
West Seneca PizzaWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$18.48
46
Ying's Restaurant & BarDepew, NY
Depew
$18.45
47
Delta Sonic Brick Oven KitchenWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$16.30
48
Hunt Brothers PizzaGrand Island, NY
Grand Island
$13.40
49
David's 716 Bar & GrillNiagara Falls, NY
Niagara Falls
$18.36
50
Osteria 166Buffalo, NY
Buffalo
$19.58
51
Union PubBuffalo, NY
Buffalo
$10.32
52
KFC ChizzaBuffalo, NY
Buffalo
$10.80
53
Bocce Club Pizza (Buffalo Airport)Cheektowaga, NY
Cheektowaga
$18.24
54
SubwayOrchard Park, NY
Orchard Park
$9.78
55
WegmansWilliamsville, NY
Williamsville
$16.80
56
Queen City Kitchen (Buffalo Airport)Cheektowaga, NY
Cheektowaga
$17.93
57
Little CaesarsLockport, NY
Lockport
$10.25
58
7-ElevenLackawanna, NY
Lackawanna
$7.92
59
Prime Food & Meat MarketBuffalo, NY
Buffalo
$11.33
60
Anchor BarBuffalo, NY
Buffalo
$18.80
On Camera
Watch the top picks
Prices are what Joe paid at the time of his visit.
Know a spot Joe missed?
Send it in. The best tips become the next review on the channel.