Rankings Towns Reviews About Joe Recommend a Spot Full Rankings
Home/Towns/Amherst
Amherst, New York

Best pizza in Amherst, NY

Amherst has everything from local favorites to big names and chains, which makes it one of the most interesting places on the list. A big reputation doesn’t guarantee a big score here.

11Pizzerias ranked
8.6Top score
$26.34Average price
#1 in Amherst

The best pizza in Amherst

Papa's Pizza Oven pizza review
#1 in Amherst
8.6SCORE

Papa's Pizza Oven

Price $30.44Overall rank #60 of 236

The top-scoring pizza Joe has found in Amherst. Watch the full review and see why it beat the rest.

Watch the review

Nearby towns

Best pizza in Buffalo52Best pizza in Niagara Falls27Best pizza in Tonawanda20Best pizza in Cheektowaga19Best pizza in West Seneca14Best pizza in Depew11Best pizza in Orchard Park11Best pizza in Williamsville11Best pizza in Lockport10Best pizza in North Tonawanda9

Short lists

Full Buffalo rankings236Best under $2060Best of the Northtowns61Best of the Southtowns35
On Camera

Watch the Amherst reviews

All reviews
Papa's Pizza Oven pizza review
8.6

Papa's Pizza Oven

Amherst, NY · $30.44
Zetti's Pizza & Pasta pizza review
8.6

Zetti's Pizza & Pasta

Amherst, NY · $24.02
Mister Pizza pizza review
8.5

Mister Pizza

Amherst, NY · $23.16
Bocce Club Pizza pizza review
8.3

Bocce Club Pizza

Amherst, NY · $29.45

Know a spot Joe missed?

Send it in. The best tips become the next review on the channel.

Recommend a Pizzeria