Rankings Towns Reviews About Joe Recommend a Spot Full Rankings
Home/Towns
Buffalo & Niagara

Best pizza by town

Pick your town and see every pizzeria Joe has scored there, ranked from best to the rest. From downtown Buffalo up the river to Youngstown.

24Towns covered
236Pizzerias ranked
52 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Buffalo

#1: Buffalo Deep Dish · 9.1
27 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Niagara Falls

#1: Sammy's Pizzeria · 8.9
20 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Tonawanda

#1: John's Pizza & Subs (Niagara Falls Blvd) · 9.1
19 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Cheektowaga

#1: Tony's Pizza · 9.0
14 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in West Seneca

#1: Picasso's Pizza · 9.1
11 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Amherst

#1: Papa's Pizza Oven · 8.6
11 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Depew

#1: D'Agostino's Pizzeria · 8.7
11 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Orchard Park

#1: Wayland Brewing Company · 8.9
11 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Williamsville

#1: Mattina's Pizzeria · 8.9
10 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Lockport

#1: Mark's Pizzeria · 8.2
9 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in North Tonawanda

#1: Pizza Amore · 8.7
6 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Lancaster

#1: Picasso's Pizza · 9.0
5 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Alden

#1: Carbone's Pizzeria · 8.7
5 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Grand Island

#1: Brick Oven Pizzeria & Pub · 8.6
5 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Hamburg

#1: Nino's Pizzeria · 8.9
3 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Kenmore

#1: Macy's Place Pizzeria · 9.3
3 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Lewiston

#1: Favorites Pizza & Wings · 8.9
3 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Wheatfield

#1: The Original Pizza Shack · 8.4
3 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Youngstown

#1: Grandma D's Pizzeria · 8.8

More towns Joe has visited

Blasdell: Picasso's Pizza8.2Clarence: Gianni Mazia's on Main8.2Lackawanna: Bella Pizza8.0East Aurora: Pizzeria Florian9.4Sanborn: Tony's Pizza7.3
Town by town

The #1 pie in every town

Rank
Pizzeria
Town
Price
Joe’s Score
02
Macy's Place PizzeriaKenmore, NY
Kenmore
$23.84
9.3
03
Buffalo Deep DishBuffalo, NY
Buffalo
$17.75
9.1
04
John's Pizza & Subs (Niagara Falls Blvd)Tonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$25.76
9.1
06
Picasso's PizzaWest Seneca, NY
West Seneca
$29.85
9.1
09
Tony's PizzaCheektowaga, NY
Cheektowaga
$22.83
9.0
08
Picasso's PizzaLancaster, NY
Lancaster
$32.30
9.0
19
Sammy's PizzeriaNiagara Falls, NY
Niagara Falls
$17.05
8.9
20
Wayland Brewing CompanyOrchard Park, NY
Orchard Park
$20.66
8.9
15
Mattina's PizzeriaWilliamsville, NY
Williamsville
$28.38
8.9
16
Nino's PizzeriaHamburg, NY
Hamburg
$27.80
8.9
12
Favorites Pizza & WingsLewiston, NY
Lewiston
$21.15
8.9
22
Grandma D's PizzeriaYoungstown, NY
Youngstown
$18.50
8.8
35
D'Agostino's PizzeriaDepew, NY
Depew
$21.20
8.7
44
Pizza AmoreNorth Tonawanda, NY
North Tonawanda
$25.38
8.7
34
Carbone's PizzeriaAlden, NY
Alden
$18.92
8.7
60
Papa's Pizza OvenAmherst, NY
Amherst
$30.44
8.6
47
Brick Oven Pizzeria & PubGrand Island, NY
Grand Island
$27.49
8.6
96
The Original Pizza ShackWheatfield, NY
Wheatfield
$24.84
8.4
124
Mark's PizzeriaLockport, NY
Lockport
$23.75
8.2

Know a spot Joe missed?

Send it in. The best tips become the next review on the channel.

Recommend a Pizzeria