Rank
Pizzeria
Town
Price
Joe’s Score
01
Macy's Place PizzeriaKenmore, NY
Kenmore
$23.84
02
John's Pizza & Subs (Niagara Falls Blvd)Tonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$25.76
03
DiPaulo's PizzeriaTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$23.65
04
Mattina's PizzeriaWilliamsville, NY
Williamsville
$28.38
05
Gino's Pizza PlaceTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$28.00
06
Pizza AmoreNorth Tonawanda, NY
North Tonawanda
$25.38
07
Brick Oven Pizzeria & PubGrand Island, NY
Grand Island
$27.49
08
Caputi's Sheridan PubTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$15.22
09
Franco's PizzaTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$33.40
10
Good Guys PizzaNorth Tonawanda, NY
North Tonawanda
$21.50
11
Papa's Pizza OvenAmherst, NY
Amherst
$30.44
12
Pizza Amore the Woodfire WayGrand Island, NY
Grand Island
$25.56
13
Zetti's Pizza & PastaAmherst, NY
Amherst
$24.02
14
Jay's Artisan PizzeriaKenmore, NY
Kenmore
$18.45
15
Joe's New York Style PizzaTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$24.96
16
La Hacienda BrightonTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$25.50
17
Mister PizzaAmherst, NY
Amherst
$23.16
18
Muscarella's PizzaWilliamsville, NY
Williamsville
$22.39
19
Franco's Pizza (Niagara Falls Blvd)Tonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$33.40
20
Galassi's Sub ShopNorth Tonawanda, NY
North Tonawanda
$23.22
21
Naked City PizzaKenmore, NY
Kenmore
$15.50
22
Pane's RestaurantNorth Tonawanda, NY
North Tonawanda
$24.82
23
Trattoria AromaWilliamsville, NY
Williamsville
$19.58
24
Bocce Club PizzaAmherst, NY
Amherst
$29.45
25
Campobello's PizzaAmherst, NY
Amherst
$33.40
26
Fatman's PizzaTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$26.90
27
Mayor's PizzaNorth Tonawanda, NY
North Tonawanda
$21.55
28
A Touch of ItalyTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$23.10
29
Gianni Mazia's on MainClarence, NY
Clarence
$21.37
30
John's Pizza & SubsGrand Island, NY
Grand Island
$25.76
31
Just Pizza & Wing Co.Tonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$26.60
32
LaPorta's PizzeriaWilliamsville, NY
Williamsville
$30.52
33
Pie O MineTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$21.74
34
Sorrentino's Spaghetti HouseWilliamsville, NY
Williamsville
$21.20
35
Rob's Topico PizzaClarence, NY
Clarence
$22.50
36
T.C. Wheelers Bar & PizzeriaTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$26.92
37
Palumbo's PizzeriaTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$16.85
38
Franco's PizzaNorth Tonawanda, NY
North Tonawanda
$29.79
39
JT's PizzaTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$23.33
40
John's Pizza & Subs (Delaware Ave)Tonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$25.21
41
La Nova PizzeriaAmherst, NY
Amherst
$33.38
42
Amherst Pizza and Ale HouseAmherst, NY
Amherst
$29.90
43
Duff's Famous WingsWilliamsville, NY
Williamsville
$20.39
44
Olisi's New York Style PizzaTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$22.83
45
Plaza Pizzeria on MainTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$24.40
46
Rocco's Wood Fired PizzaWilliamsville, NY
Williamsville
$31.40
47
Queen City PizzaAmherst, NY
Amherst
$22.88
48
The Grill on ErieNorth Tonawanda, NY
North Tonawanda
$25.36
49
Dandelions RestaurantWilliamsville, NY
Williamsville
$21.75
50
Luigi's Pizza and CateringAmherst, NY
Amherst
$25.10
51
Raintree Bar and GrillTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$22.80
52
The Wurlitzer Pizza CoNorth Tonawanda, NY
North Tonawanda
$23.49
53
Romeo & Juliet's Bakery and CafeTonawanda, NY
Tonawanda
$19.58
54
Say Cheese Pizza CoGrand Island, NY
Grand Island
$26.90
55
Pizza Plant Italian PubWilliamsville, NY
Williamsville
$28.38
56
Blaze PizzaAmherst, NY
Amherst
$15.17
57
D'Avolio KitchenWilliamsville, NY
Williamsville
$21.70
58
My Tomato PieAmherst, NY
Amherst
$22.84
59
Hunt Brothers PizzaGrand Island, NY
Grand Island
$13.40
60
Buffalo Pizza ProjectNorth Tonawanda, NY
North Tonawanda
$32.39
61
WegmansWilliamsville, NY
Williamsville
$16.80
On Camera
Watch the top picks
The Northtowns’ best, on camera.
Know a spot Joe missed?
Send it in. The best tips become the next review on the channel.