Home/Reviews
Every Buffalo review

Joe’s Buffalo pizza reviews

237 pizzerias. Every one ordered, paid for and scored on camera. Watch the video, read the write-up, then go get a slice.

237Pizzerias reviewed
24Towns covered
9.4Top score
Mangia Ristorante & Caffe pizza

Mangia Ristorante & Caffe Review – Orchard Park, NY

September 05, 2024•1 min read
8.4
Joe’s
score
Price$11.96 · 10-inch cheese pepperoni
LocationOrchard Park, NY

Mangia Ristorante & Caffe is on North Buffalo Road in Orchard Park, just outside of Buffalo. Joe said it looks beautiful inside, like a great date night pasta place, and it smelled fantastic.

The order

The 10-inch is the size they have here. Joe got a cheese pepperoni for $11.96 with cup and char pepperoni and a distribution he liked. He admits he was seven minutes late picking it up.

First bite

Underneath, the crust had an orange look that reminded Joe of cheese crackers, goldfish in particular. But the flavors were nice, and it tasted better than he expected.

Crust, sauce, cheese and toppings

  • Crust: Thin, with good ratios. Joe guessed the crust might not be made in house, though he said he could be wrong.
  • Sauce: Really, really nice. Joe liked it a lot.
  • Cheese: Nice.
  • Pepperoni: Nice flavor and cooked well.

What would make it better

The cut needed a little help. Joe also admitted the look of the crust made him hold the score back a bit.

The verdict

It doesn't look as good as it tastes. It tastes better. Joe demolished this little pizza and gave it an 8.4, a good, solid pie that would go well with a gin and tonic.

Find Mangia Ristorante & Caffe

Orchard Park, NY

View on GoogleGet Directions

More Buffalo pizza

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez is Pizza Review Joe, the Canadian pizza reviewer who crosses the border to find the best pie in Buffalo and Niagara. He walks in, orders, pays, and scores every pizza on camera, one honest number out of 10.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog