Home/Reviews
Every Buffalo review

Joe’s Buffalo pizza reviews

237 pizzerias. Every one ordered, paid for and scored on camera. Watch the video, read the write-up, then go get a slice.

237Pizzerias reviewed
24Towns covered
9.4Top score
Sanger Farm & Bakery pizza

Sanger Farm & Bakery Review – Youngstown, NY

June 19, 2023•1 min read
7.9
Joe’s
score
Price$18.36 · Large cheese pepperoni
LocationYoungstown, NY

Sanger Farm & Bakery is on Lockport Road in Youngstown. It was Joe's first time reviewing pizza from a farm, and having grown up on one, he loved the idea.

The order

Joe ordered a large 16-inch cheese pepperoni for $18.36. It's thick, with cup and char, and looked like something his mom might make on the farm.

First bite

A thick, soft, pillowy crust with nice browning underneath. Right away, Joe felt the first improvement: when it's this thick, it needs more sauce.

Crust, sauce, cheese and toppings

  • Crust: Fantastic. A big bakery-style crust with nice flavor.
  • Sauce: Not enough of it for a crust this thick. The saucy bite had the best ratio.
  • Cheese: Good, maybe a little more.
  • Pepperoni: Cup and char with nice flavor.

What would make it better

More sauce. Joe says with more sauce, this one would easily be in the eights.

The verdict

It's a nice pizza with a great crust. Joe gave Sanger Farm & Bakery a 7.9, then headed inside for a cherry pie made with cherries grown on the farm.

Find Sanger Farm & Bakery

852 Lockport St, Youngstown, NY 14174

View on GoogleGet Directions

More Buffalo pizza

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez is Pizza Review Joe, the Canadian pizza reviewer who crosses the border to find the best pie in Buffalo and Niagara. He walks in, orders, pays, and scores every pizza on camera, one honest number out of 10.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog