Rankings Towns Reviews About Joe Recommend a Spot Full Rankings

Home/Towns/Buffalo

Buffalo, New York

Best pizza in Buffalo, NY

Buffalo is a pizza town, plain and simple. The classic Buffalo pie has a thick, airy crust, a slightly sweet sauce, plenty of cheese and pepperoni that curls into little cups and chars at the edges. Every neighborhood has its corner shop and every family has its favorite.

52Pizzerias ranked

9.1Top score

$22.96Average price

#1 in Buffalo

The best pizza in Buffalo

Buffalo Deep Dish pizza review

Buffalo Deep Dish

Price $17.75Overall rank #3 of 236

The top-scoring pizza Joe has found in Buffalo. Watch the full review and see why it beat the rest.

Watch the review

The Ranking

Every pizzeria in Buffalo

Joe has ranked 52 pizzerias inside Buffalo, from old-school shops to newer spots. Here’s where the city’s pizza really stacks up.

Rank

Pizzeria

Town

Price

Joe’s Score

Buffalo Deep DishBuffalo, NY

9.1

Marble & RyeBuffalo, NY

9.1

Bailey Avenue PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.9

Lovejoy PizzeriaBuffalo, NY

8.9

Pesci's Pizza & WingsBuffalo, NY

8.9

JJ's Casa Di PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.8

Niagara Deli & PizzeriaBuffalo, NY

8.8

Papa's Pizza Oven (Abbott Rd)Buffalo, NY

8.8

Pizza By Molino'sBuffalo, NY

8.8

Imperial PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.7

Chick N Pizza WorksBuffalo, NY

8.6

Emergency PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.6

Just Pizza & Wing Co.Buffalo, NY

8.6

Mustachio's PizzeriaBuffalo, NY

8.6

Pat's PizzeriaBuffalo, NY

8.6

Bob & John's La HaciendaBuffalo, NY

8.5

Buffalo Bites PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.5

Ricotta's Pizza NiagaraBuffalo, NY

8.5

Artone's Pizza & SubsBuffalo, NY

8.4

Desi's PizzeriaBuffalo, NY

8.3

Gino & Joe's PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.3

Blasdell PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.2

Chuck's North Street SubwayBuffalo, NY

8.2

DanielaBuffalo, NY

8.2

Diva's PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.2

Mineo's South PizzeriaBuffalo, NY

8.2

Wise Guys PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.2

Brick Oven Bistro & DeliBuffalo, NY

8.1

La Pizza ClubBuffalo, NY

8.1

Leo's PizzeriaBuffalo, NY

8.1

Mister SubmarineBuffalo, NY

8.1

Kensington PizzaBuffalo, NY

8.0

Marco's Italian RestaurantBuffalo, NY

8.0

Allentown PizzaBuffalo, NY

7.9

Carbone's Pizza & SubsBuffalo, NY

7.9

Metro Pizza CoBuffalo, NY

7.9

Mister Pizza ElmwoodBuffalo, NY

7.9

Bada Bing Bar & GrillBuffalo, NY

7.8

Franco's PizzaBuffalo, NY

7.8

Jo Jo's Pizza & SubsBuffalo, NY

7.8

La Nova PizzeriaBuffalo, NY

7.8

Abbott Road PizzaBuffalo, NY

7.7

Extra Extra PizzaBuffalo, NY

7.6

Giacobbi's Cucina CittaBuffalo, NY

7.6

Jet's PizzaBuffalo, NY

7.3

Pizza & Chicken DelightsBuffalo, NY

7.3

Fra Amici Pizza & PastaBuffalo, NY

7.2

Osteria 166Buffalo, NY

5.9

Union PubBuffalo, NY

5.9

KFC ChizzaBuffalo, NY

5.6

Prime Food & Meat MarketBuffalo, NY

2.1

Anchor BarBuffalo, NY

0.0

Nearby towns

Best pizza in Niagara Falls27 Best pizza in Tonawanda20 Best pizza in Cheektowaga19 Best pizza in West Seneca14 Best pizza in Amherst11 Best pizza in Depew11 Best pizza in Orchard Park11 Best pizza in Williamsville11 Best pizza in Lockport10 Best pizza in North Tonawanda9

Short lists

Full Buffalo rankings236 Best under $2060 Best of the Northtowns61 Best of the Southtowns35

On Camera

Watch the Buffalo reviews

Buffalo Deep Dish pizza review

Buffalo Deep Dish

Buffalo, NY · $17.75

Marble & Rye pizza review

Marble & Rye

Buffalo, NY · $21.75

Bailey Avenue Pizza pizza review

Bailey Avenue Pizza

Buffalo, NY · $32.50

Lovejoy Pizzeria pizza review

Lovejoy Pizzeria

Buffalo, NY · $21.70

Know a spot Joe missed?

Send it in. The best tips become the next review on the channel.

Recommend a Pizzeria