Muscarella's Pizzeria Review – Lancaster, NY
8.4
Joe’s
score
score
Price$26.87 · Large cheese pepperoni
LocationLancaster, NY
Muscarella's Pizzeria is on Aurora Street in Lancaster. The owner told Joe he'd like it because of the cup and char.
The order
Joe ordered a large 16-inch cheese pepperoni for $26.87. It came with a bar style cut into squares and cup and char pepperoni.
First bite
The crust is medium to thick, but considering the thickness it's not heavy. It's pillowy and soft, with browning underneath that looks almost like grilled cheese.
Crust, sauce, cheese and toppings
- Crust: Soft and pillowy, not heavy.
- Sauce: Nice and not too sweet.
- Cheese: Fantastic.
- Pepperoni: Good flavor, nicely charred on the outside.
- Toppings: Joe liked that they go to the edge.
What would make it better
Just a little more sauce. That would have tipped it higher.
The verdict
This is a solid pizza. Joe gave it an 8.4.
Find Muscarella's Pizzeria
470 Aurora St, Lancaster, NY 14086
