Best pizza in Youngstown, NY

Youngstown sits where the Niagara River meets Lake Ontario, near Old Fort Niagara. It’s a small village, but it’s home to one of the top-rated pies in the whole region.

3Pizzerias ranked

8.8Top score

$18.98Average price

#1 in Youngstown

The best pizza in Youngstown

#1 in Youngstown

8.8SCORE

Grandma D's Pizzeria

Price $18.50Overall rank #22 of 236

The top-scoring pizza Joe has found in Youngstown. Watch the full review and see why it beat the rest.

Watch the review

The Ranking

Every pizzeria in Youngstown

Joe has ranked 3 pizzerias in Youngstown. Here’s how they score.

Rank

Pizzeria

Town

Price

Joe’s Score

01

Grandma D's PizzeriaYoungstown, NY

Youngstown

$18.50

8.8

02

Main Street PizzeriaYoungstown, NY

Youngstown

$20.08

8.5

03

Sanger Farm & BakeryYoungstown, NY

Youngstown

$18.36

7.9

Nearby towns

Best pizza in Buffalo52 Best pizza in Niagara Falls27 Best pizza in Tonawanda20 Best pizza in Cheektowaga19 Best pizza in West Seneca14 Best pizza in Amherst11 Best pizza in Depew11 Best pizza in Orchard Park11 Best pizza in Williamsville11 Best pizza in Lockport10

Short lists

Full Buffalo rankings236 Best under $2060 Best of the Northtowns61 Best of the Southtowns35

On Camera

Watch the Youngstown reviews

All reviews

8.8

Know a spot Joe missed?

Send it in. The best tips become the next review on the channel.

Recommend a Pizzeria