Home/Reviews
Every Buffalo review

Joe’s Buffalo pizza reviews

237 pizzerias. Every one ordered, paid for and scored on camera. Watch the video, read the write-up, then go get a slice.

237Pizzerias reviewed
24Towns covered
9.4Top score
Papa's Pizza Oven at Legacy Sports Bar Review – West Seneca, NY

Papa's Pizza Oven at Legacy Sports Bar Review – West Seneca, NY

Papa's Pizza Oven at Legacy Sports Bar Review – West Seneca, NYJoe Gonzalez
Published on: 16/01/2025

Pizza Review Joe scores Papa's Pizza Oven at Legacy Sports Bar in West Seneca a 9.0. Sauce and cheese to the edge with real charred cup and char.

papa's pizza oven at legacy sports barwest seneca pizzabuffalo pizzapizza review
Crosby's Review – West Seneca, NY

Crosby's Review – West Seneca, NY

Crosby's Review – West Seneca, NYJoe Gonzalez
Published on: 14/01/2025

Pizza Review Joe scores Crosby's gas station pizza on Seneca Street a 6.8. Perfectly cooked cup and char on a soft crust, for under 20 bucks.

crosby'swest seneca pizzabuffalo pizzapizza review
Delta Sonic Brick Oven Kitchen Review – West Seneca, NY

Delta Sonic Brick Oven Kitchen Review – West Seneca, NY

Delta Sonic Brick Oven Kitchen Review – West Seneca, NYJoe Gonzalez
Published on: 07/01/2025

Pizza Review Joe scores the Brick Oven Kitchen at Delta Sonic in West Seneca a 6.3. Great cheese and real cup and char at a gas station, held back by the sauce.

delta sonic brick oven kitchenwest seneca pizzabuffalo pizzapizza review
Ferro's Famous NY Pizza Review – West Seneca, NY

Ferro's Famous NY Pizza Review – West Seneca, NY

Ferro's Famous NY Pizza Review – West Seneca, NYJoe Gonzalez
Published on: 01/01/2025

Pizza Review Joe scores Ferro's Famous NY Pizza in West Seneca an 8.9. A huge, thin New York style slice with phenomenal cheese, said to be Josh Allen's favorite.

ferro's famous ny pizzawest seneca pizzabuffalo pizzapizza review