Home/Reviews
Every Buffalo review

Joe’s Buffalo pizza reviews

237 pizzerias. Every one ordered, paid for and scored on camera. Watch the video, read the write-up, then go get a slice.

237Pizzerias reviewed
24Towns covered
9.4Top score
Papa's Pizza Oven Review – Amherst, NY

Papa's Pizza Oven Review – Amherst, NY

Papa's Pizza Oven Review – Amherst, NYJoe Gonzalez
Published on: 07/01/2026

Pizza Review Joe scores Papa's Pizza Oven on Niagara Falls Blvd in Amherst an 8.6. Hand cut pepperoni and sauce and cheese right to the edge.

papa's pizza ovenamherst pizzabuffalo pizzapizza review
Campobello's Pizza Review – Amherst, NY

Campobello's Pizza Review – Amherst, NY

Campobello's Pizza Review – Amherst, NYJoe Gonzalez
Published on: 19/08/2024

Pizza Review Joe scores Campobello's Pizza in East Amherst an 8.3. A homemade tasting crust, thick cut cup and char and a sauce that doesn't overpower.

campobello's pizzaamherst pizzabuffalo pizzapizza review
La Nova Pizzeria Review – Amherst, NY

La Nova Pizzeria Review – Amherst, NY

La Nova Pizzeria Review – Amherst, NYJoe Gonzalez
Published on: 14/08/2024

Pizza Review Joe scores La Nova Pizzeria on Main Street in Amherst a 7.9. A thin crust under a thick layer of cheese, with a sauce a little too rich for him.

la nova pizzeriaamherst pizzabuffalo pizzapizza review
Luigi's Pizza and Catering Review – Amherst, NY

Luigi's Pizza and Catering Review – Amherst, NY

Luigi's Pizza and Catering Review – Amherst, NYJoe Gonzalez
Published on: 11/01/2024

Pizza Review Joe scores Luigi's Pizza and Catering in East Amherst a 7.4. Good pepperoni and crust, with cheese and sauce that fall a little flat.

luigi's pizza and cateringamherst pizzabuffalo pizzapizza review